For a discussion of the value chain framework, see michael e porter, competitive advantage: a version of this article appeared in the january 2008 issue of harvard business review. By virginia messina, mph, rd as a vegan health professional, i am sometimes mortified to be associated with the junk science that permeates our community and as an animal rights activist, i’m disheartened by advocacy efforts that can make us look scientifically illiterate, dishonest, and occasionally like a cult of conspiracy theorists. Leading discussion of a scientific journal article leading discussion of a scientific journal article by t w sherry and leading group discussions leading a discussion of a scientific work is a hybrid of several kinds of skills — leading a discussion group, reading a scientific paper at a meeting, review key methods, findings, and. Article review samples reviewing an article is not as easy as it sounds: it requires a critical mind and doing some extra research check out our article review samples to gain a better understanding of how to review articles yourself.
The parts of the discussion i focus on most are context and whether the authors make claims that overreach the data i solved it by making the decision to review one journal article per week. The class was involved in a heated discussion about politics i hope to have a discussion with them about the matter soon after much discussion of the plan, the idea was rejected entirely during the period under discussion, the town grew in size the smoking ban is a major topic of discussion these days the article is an in-depth discussion of his theories. The following video, understanding scholarly journal articles, provides an introduction to the process of writing a journal article for submission the video discusses the purpose of publication, how scholarly journals differ from other publications, the steps in the publication process, the parts of basic journal article, and tips on writing. How to write an article review three parts: preparing to write your review writing the article review sample article reviews community q&a an article review is both a summary and an evaluation of another writer's article teachers often assign article reviews to introduce students to the work of experts in the field.
Editor’s note: this third installment of posts for peer review week is a guest post from tom culley and the team at publons for centuries academic journals have brought modern research from around the globe into regularly published pages for consumption. The third and final in a series of editorials (drotar, 2009a,b), this article provides guidance for authors to prepare effective results and discussion sections. Right about this time of year is when the literary world would normally be praising, bemoaning or just scratching its collective head over the latest winner of the nobel prize in literature.
The literature review consists of an introduction, summary of scholarly sources, a discussion and evaluation of the sources (including disputes and disagreements), and a conclusion in which you put forth your own potential original research questions that will contribute something new to the available understanding on the topic. A comprehensive and critical review essay of homosexuality, science, and the “plain sense” of scripture, part 2 robert a j gagnon [email protected] pittsburgh theological seminary, pittsburgh, pa 15206-2596. (photo: blvdone/dreamstime) there are good reasons not to confine the discussion to academic journals i n the latest issue of national review, john mcwhorter has a challenging and thought. Law review & journal articles on the death penalty this edition of the new york city law review features remarks and discussion from the american bar association's october 12, 2000, program at the carter center regarding the death penalty and the aba's call for a moratorium on executions. Interesting discussion one other idea about how ensure or improve diversity in peer review is to ask a truly diverse group of people how to ensure or improve diversity in peer review.
Beyond explaining the relevance of discussion in general, it is a good idea to point out the relevance of particular discussions vis-à-vis contemporary social issues, your students’ future plans, etc. An article was considered to be written using the imrad structure only when the headings “methods, results, and discussion,” or synonyms for these headings, were all included and clearly printed the introduction section had to be present but not necessarily accompanied by a heading. A review article is a secondary sourceit is written about other articles, and does not report original research of its own review articles are very important, as they draw upon the articles that they review to suggest new research directions, to strengthen support for existing theories and/or identify patterns among exising research studies. Recall from the initial discussion of review papers that these publications make two kinds of contribution: 1) an organized summary of the current state of an area of research 2) critical commentary from the writer who eventually recommends directions for further research.
Reviewers at the new yorker, the new york review of books, and the paris review voice their concerns about the pulitzer prize–winning book. Review - an essay or article that gives a critical evaluation (as of a book or play) critical review, critique, review - a summary at the end that repeats the substance of a longer discussion recap, recapitulation capitulation - a summary that enumerates the main parts of a topic. Aim to make the contents of the performance review discussion a re-emphasis of critical points in the interest of providing regular feedback, performance reviews are not an annual event quarterly meetings are recommended with employees. It offers a process and suggests some strategies for writing book reviews what is a review a review is a critical evaluation of a text, event, object, or phenomenon not merely a summary it allows you to enter into dialogue and discussion with the work’s creator and with other audiences you can offer agreement or disagreement and.
How to write a play review three parts: sample play reviews preparing to write the review writing the review community q&a the performance of a play is a live experience, so it can be an exciting but difficult task to review you have to be both the spectator, taking in and enjoying the performance, and a critic, analyzing the production. Writing a critical review of a journal article can help to improve your research skills by assessing the work of others, you develop skills as a critical reader and become familiar with the types of evaluation criteria that will be applied to research in your ﬁeld and thus your own research. What the health starts off with a fairly credible position (in most people’s eyes) of raising the question of the safety of processed meats and red meat in particular lots of people buy that, even if they still eat them.